Homepage / Call of Cthulhu / Cthulhu Edition Wars
Two Years On Roll20 The Great Comprehensive “What Should I Buy For Call of Cthulhu?” Post The Dracula Dossier–Six Months In The Dracula Dossier Cthulhu Edition Wars Gumshoe Thoughts Roll20 Changed My Life An Update Goodbye to the Higgins Armory Diablo 3 & A New PC Guild Wars 2 — First Impressions Stop me The SWTOR Beta Review: The Sith Emperor Has No Clothes Lost in Space… Incarna is Here. And I overestimated it. Blog Banter 25: Nerfing Nulsec There Is No Lowsec. And this is as personal as it will ever get. The Era of Nulsec Peace Has Begun! That IT Thing… 3.1415926535897932384626433832795 6VDT Siege: Too Hot For Me! Victory At Z3 Amazon Goes Incarna New Portraits aka WoD alpha And that makes a year… PI Interlude Another Day… Happy Christmas IT! Blog Banter 23: Nobody Will Use Incarna — the remix In which our heroine returns to space… Good Grief! Belated Blog Banter 20 Thoughts on New Fleet Paradigms Back to Space! No, this blog isn’t dead… The Quiet Life I Live in a World of Tanks CCP Doesn’t Care: Blog Banter 19 Idiocy Incarna(te) Goodbye to Curse How Many Licks? B0RT’s Message to Southern Renters Returning Rifter Bad Intel A Politically Correct Carebear Joins Goonswarm: Blog Banter 18 Oh My Head… We Can’t Stop Here… Objects at rest… “I need a volunteer…” OMG You’re a Chick?! Dreddit Video of H-W WoW 3.3 and Me: I Want The World The Siege of H-W The Goons 2010 Newbie Guide Back to the Future Return to the North! This week in my Eve This Week in Eve Blogging… How Do You Solve A Problem Like Kharai? Hawaiian Shirts and Shorts… Bye CVA Parody Song Points of Departure Into the void… The Alliance of the Beast Marking Time Women in Eve Just what New Eden needed, another Eve blog

I don’t think it’s particularly a radical statement to say that among some people, 7th Edition Call of Cthulhu is controversial. I don’t quite get it myself because I love 7th and think it’s the best edition ever, but the vicious anger that some people have towards “crap-thulhu” seems to be as sincere as it is forceful.

This weekend, I developed a theory. I’m playing in a Call game and we had a rules dispute with the GM and he wrote off something as “7th edition crap” and overruled something that would have given a couple of us an escape from insanity.

Here’s the thing. I wondered how it played out in 6th so I pulled it out and read the rule. It was the same! I have 1st, 5th, and 5.61¬†and I poked at them as well. I found that the “new 7th edition rule” actually goes back to first edition. I’ve played from first edition. I didn’t remember it. In fact, I remember reading it in the 7th edition rulebook and thinking “oh that’s clever.” I started to look at some of the other rules that I had been surprised by in 7th, even some I’ve had online discussions about, and discovered that they too had been part of the game for several editions.


I did notice that some of these weren’t really highlighted in earlier editions. They were in text boxes or things like that. Easy to overlook and far better integrated in the new edition–even though in my opinion there are plenty of issues with the new edition. And most everyone selectively reads when they first pick up a new set of rules and often there’s a sort of free floating general consensus about what rules everyone was going to ignore.

So after all this, what I wonder is how much of the animosity towards 7th edition comes from the actual differences and how much comes from¬†people actually reading the rules (because they know it’s not just a new layout) and the book being organized well enough to actually notice the rules they never knew were there?

Comments are closed.